In the ongoing tile vs. asphalt shingles debate, there’s often a question of which has the best long-term value. Everyone knows asphalt shingles cost less, but tile lasts longer. Ever wondered which wins out in long-term costs? In this article, we’ll break down the differences between tile vs. asphalt shingles, focusing on their long-term value.
Tile Roofing
Tile is the gold standard of high quality roofs. Historically it has proven its ability to stand up to all kinds of weather in dozens of different climates.
1. Durability:
Tiles are exceptionally durable. They can stand up to Mother Nature’s worst, from heavy storms to scorching sun. They can crack if something falls on them, but they rarely degrade over time like shingles do. This means fewer repairs and a longer lifespan, which is excellent for your peace of mind, budget, and avoiding additional damages to your home.
2. Low Maintenance:
Tile roofs are pretty low-maintenance. As long as the roof is well installed, you’ll seldom have to deal with repairs even as the roofs gets older.
3. Style Options:
When you choose tile, you have dozens of options in regard to shape and color. There are many different styles to choose from for both looks and functionality.
4. Energy Efficiency:
Tiles are fantastic insulators. They keep your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter, leading to energy savings. With the hot summers we have in Arizona, it’s a big deal to have your home’s insulation and AC system working perfectly in tandem.
5. Longevity:
Tile roofs can last well over 50 years. This is where the real value of tile comes in. You don’t have to replace it frequently, perhaps not even in your lifetime.
6. Cost Over Time:
While the upfront cost is higher than asphalt shingles, the minimal maintenance, energy savings, and long life make tile roofing a solid investment in the long run.
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles get the job done, and they’re much less expensive than any other option for a sloped roof. If you’re on a budget and are trying to decide tile vs. asphalt shingle, this might be your best option.
1. Affordability:
Asphalt shingles are the most affordable of any material option. If you’re suddenly needing to replace a roof that you didn’t plan for
2. Style:
With shingles you have many choices in regard to color, and some minor variations in shape.
3. Style Options:
When you choose tile, you have dozens of options in regard to shape and color.
4. Regular Maintenance:
Asphalt shingles have a tendency to lose material, crack, split, wear down, or come loose. It will require regular maintenance to maintain. They are easier to repair
5. Energy Efficiency:
Asphalt shingles (like asphalt roads) absorb and transfer a massive amount of heat. They also lie flat on your roof, whereas tiles have airflow underneath them. This means a shingle roof will allow more heat into your home during the summer. But don’t be too alarmed; your roof isn’t going to drive your energy bill up too much. If you want to reduce your energy bill it’s much more worthwhile to look at your windows.
6. Lifespan:
The sacrifice you pay for a low up-front cost, is the short lifespan of shingle roofs. They are generally only going to last 15-25 years, and will take more maintenance along the way.
When are Asphalt Shingle The Best Choice?
Low-Budget Emergency Replacement
If you suddenly need to replace a roof and aren’t able to afford a tile roof, then it makes far more sense to install a shingle roof.Short Term Residence
If you don’t plan on staying in a home for many years, but the roof needs to be replaced, it may make more sense to make a short-term investment in a shingle roof.Easy (but more frequent) Repairs
Asphalt shingles are relatively easy (and inexpensive) to repair, which can be an advantage if you live in an area prone to minor damage, like wind-blown debris. Swift repairs can extend your roof’s lifespan and reduce long-term costs.Good for Mild Climates
In regions with mild climates and fewer extreme weather events, asphalt shingles can perform well. They provide adequate protection against standard weather conditions without requiring the robust durability needed in harsher climates. Be warned that in Arizona the heat will cause substantial damage to asphalt shingles.Very Complex Roof Shape
If your home features a complex or irregular roof shape, asphalt shingles can be more versatile and adaptable than tile roofing. Their flexibility simplifies installation on a variety of roof configurations.
When is Tile The Best Choice?
Forever Homes
If you’re settled in for the long haul and envision your current house as your forever home, tile roofing is a fantastic choice. Its incredible longevity, often exceeding 50 years, means you won’t have to worry about frequent replacements. This offers unmatched value, as you’ll likely never need to replace your roof during your ownership.Aesthetic Appeal
For those who appreciate aesthetics and the timeless appeal of a Mediterranean or Spanish villa-inspired home, tile roofing is hard to beat. It not only enhances your home’s curb appeal but also adds resale value.Minimal Maintenance
Tile roofing requires minimal maintenance, sparing you the time, effort, and expenses associated with frequent repairs. It’s the hassle-free option for homeowners who prefer not to worry constantly about their roof.Resale Value
If you’re planning to sell your home in the future, tile roofing can significantly boost your property’s resale value. It’s a feature that potential buyers often find attractive due to its durability and aesthetic appeal.Harsh Climates
In regions with extreme weather conditions, such as frequent storms or scorching sun, tile roofing’s robust durability is a lifeline. It can withstand these challenges without flinching, offering your home reliable protection.
In summary, tile roofing is the ideal choice when long-term durability, energy efficiency, aesthetics, minimal maintenance, and resale value are your primary considerations. It’s a long-term investment that pays dividends in various ways over the years.
The Value Verdict: Tile vs Asphalt Shingles
If you look at the cost comparison, tile is approximately twice as expensive to install as common asphalt shingles, but lasts more than twice as long and is more durable. Shingle roofs have complications and leaks more frequently.
When you look at the long term costs of tile vs. asphalt shingle roofing, as well as the amount of hassle and expense from repairs, tile roofing is the more cost-efficient of the two.
If you have an upcoming roof replacement, plan out the costs to determine which type of roof best suits your long-term goals for your home. If you can afford it and plan on staying in your home for a long time, we highly recommend tile for long term savings and convenience. If you live in Arizona, contact us! We’d love to get you a quote.